Showing posts with label Behavior and Lifecycles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Behavior and Lifecycles. Show all posts

27 September, 2021

Bird Table Life

 Bird Table Life 


Wintery Window Feeder Setup, Townhome Bird Table Jan 2018


The arrival of autumn in the Carolinas brings more than just cooler air, shorter days, and breathtaking sunsets (or foliage in Appalachia) . Songbirds and migratory raptors are passing through woodlands, hedgerows, and gardens in search of food and water, or waiting for favorable winds to assist them on their journey south or towards the coast. Butterflies including Monarchs, Sulphurs, and Skippers are at their peak, while cicadas, katydids, and crickets are in full chorus. Bees, wasps, and hoverflies visit the first round of autumn wildflowers such as asters, early-blooming goldenrods, or morning glory. Squirrels and Field Mice are stocking up for the winter. You may also notice that birdfeeders and bird tables are busy as birds shift their diets or visit during migration. In this article I will describe some of the behaviors and habits that I have observed over the years with references from various readings.

  

General Bird Table Behaviors

Your bird table or feeder station offers a glimpse into the lives of birds and is a good place for beginners, casual gardeners/nature lovers, and experienced birdwatchers to learn about bird behavior. You will see social interactions within species (intraspecies interactions) and between different species of birds (interspecies interactions). With time, you may find that birds have habits and routines like humans, form family and nonfamily relationships, and can even recognize people. Below is a overview of some behaviors and habits that you will see amongst common birds and select mammals near bird tables, along with descriptions and habits.

Feeding Habits


Chickadee and Oriole, Townhome Bird Table, Winter 2017-2018

One of the first things an observer will notice at their bird table are the differences in feeding styles and preferences. Small woodland birds such as chickadees, titmice, and nuthatches take seeds away from the feeder to hack open in trees or nearby shrubs. Other birds such as Cardinals, House Finches, Siskins, Indigo Buntings, and Goldfinches remain at the feeder for minutes at a time. Some birds such as sparrows, Brown Thrashers, and Mourning Doves generally remain on or near the ground whilst woodpeckers prefer to brace themselves to vertical surfaces. With time and patience, you can identify most garden birds by their feeding habits, and general behaviors. Below is a overview of feeding habits amongst common birds as well as some mammals.


Carolina Chickadee at cage feeder, Wilmington Garden 2011

Carolina Chickadee: A very small bird that moves energetically and is one of several species that visits feeders almost daily. They usually carry off seeds, nuts, or peanuts to hammer open in a nearby tree, shrub, or even on railings, gutters, or sturdy plants. Chickadees hold seeds between their feet to peck them open, before flying back to the feeder to get more. They store food in crevice year-round. Carolina Chickadees rarely come on the ground, though its large counterparts from the north such as the Black-Capped, and Boreal Chickadees will feed on the ground. They come in groups of 3-15 birds, sometimes more during the autumn and winter. Chickadees are often the first birds to find a new bird table or feeder setup and will readily take food from the hand or recognize people. This bird also nests near human habitation including in birdhouses, or crevices in buildings, and is present in virtually any garden or public area with shrubs, trees, or established perennials. 


Tufted Titmouse at another squirrel proof feeder, Wilmington Garden 2010


Tufted Titmouse: Much larger than Carolina Chickadee with a distinct crest, and long tail (think of it as a miniature Blue Jay or small parrot). They are just as energetic as chickadees and are often seen together in mixed flocks. Titmice have the same habits as chickadees with the birds carrying off seeds or nuts to hammer open between their feet, and will fly back and forth to feeders. Titmice will feed on open bird tables, trays, or directly on the ground, while chickadees rarely touch the ground. They come in groups of 3-8 birds, sometimes more during the autumn or winter. They are more likely to be found in forested neighborhoods, homesites within woodlands, or around mature oaks, beeches, hickories, sycamores, and maples but can be found in most gardens in the Carolinas. 


Brown Headed Nuthatch, Wilmington Garden, 2011


Nuthatches: All three species are easily told from chickadees and titmice by their habit of creeping up or down vertical surfaces, and their short legs, long chisel-like beak, and short tail. Brown-Headed and Red-Breasted Nuthatches are only slightly larger than Carolina Chickadees and are very energetic and gregarious, while the White-Breasted Nuthatch is much larger (same size as Downy Woodpecker) and is sluggish. All species generally carry off seeds or nuts from the feeder and wedge them into crevices to store or hack open with their beak. Brown Headed Nuthatches and some times White or Red Breasted Nuthatches will feed on the ground, and may stay still at suet feeders, seed blocks, or to hack open large nuts that they cannot carry off. Brown Headed Nuthatches come in flocks of 10-20 birds, Red Breasted Nuthatches come in groups of 3-6, while White Breasted Nuthatches are usually solitary or in pairs. In general, nuthatches are found around mature trees or established woodlands with Brown Headed and Red Breasted Nuthatches are associated with conifers such as pines, spruce, fir, and hemlocks. 


Downy Woodpecker, Townhome Bird Table, Spring 2019

Woodpeckers: All woodpeckers are easily identified by their upright posture, habit of clinging to vertical surfaces, and their chisel-like bills, and short legs. Unlike nuthatches, Woodpeckers as well as Treecreepers have spiked tails that allows them to brace to vertical surfaces. Five of the eight woodpecker species in the Carolinas will visit bird tables with most birds coming from autumn to spring. Most species carry off nuts or seeds to hammer open in trees or to stock (same way as nuthatches), although Downy, Hairy, and Pileated Woodpeckers generally visit suet or lard feeders and remain still while they hammer at the contents. Red-Bellied, Red-Headed, and Pileated Woodpeckers will also feed on the ground, open bird tables, or other horizonal surfaces. Woodpecker are easy to distinguish as Downy Woodpeckers are small, black and white birds (about 14-16cm 5.5-6.5" long, or the same size as a titmouse or White Breasted Nuthatch), while Pileated Woodpeckers are as large as crows, with large crests and long beaks. The other woodpeckers fall between these extremes and have distinct head patterns (Hairy Woodpeckers are identical to Downy Woodpeckers except larger). All woodpeckers generally come singly or in pairs though Red Headed Woodpeckers come in family groups of 10-20 and Pileated Woodpeckers also stay in family pods (beyond the fledgling stage). Almost any garden will likely host Red-Bellied, Downy, and often Pileated Woodpeckers and it will not be long before one of those species (often Red-Bellied or Downy), to find a new feeder, while Hairy Woodpeckers are likely present in areas with mature conifers or hardwoods. The Red-Headed Woodpecker is a bird of the countryside and is found in areas with scattered oaks, pines, or beeches including suburbs, schoolyards, and cemeteries, as well as urban greenspaces.  


Male Cardinal, Townhome Bird Table, Spring 2019

Northern Cardinal: Cardinals are among the most common songbirds in the Carolinas and like chickadees, they will become loyal visitors to feeder stations once they find them. This bird is unmistakable with adults being about 23cm (9") long with males being all red except for their black face and females being olive colored. They have crests and long tails, and besides the Scarlet and Summer Tanagers (in the same family), Cardinals are the only red birds in the region. Cardinals will eat just about anything at a bird table but love sunflower seeds, safflower, and during the spring-summer, mealworms. They also nest within gardens and dooryards and like the Carolina Wren, chickadee, and Northern Mockingbird, they rarely travel far from their home ranges. At the feeders, cardinals are generally docile birds although they can be aggressive towards their own kind and will maintain a perimeter around them and can stand up to bullies. I found that cardinals (especially the females) may be aggressive toward House Sparrows, White-Crowned, White-Throated, and Field Sparrows, House Finches, Brown-Headed Cowbirds, and Indigo Buntings. However, Grey Catbirds, Baltimore Orioles, and Brown Thrashers may attack cardinals. Cardinals are very tame and approachable and will wait in shrubs while you put out the feeder or refill it. This bird has some interesting habits including their tendency to perform courtship displays at feeders, and gender-specific territoriality. Males and females sing and chase rival birds during the summer, but form large flocks (sometimes mixed with Hedge Sparrows such as White-Throated or Song Sparrows), from autumn to early spring. Cardinals also are among the first birds to visit a feeder in the morning with the first males arriving before sunrise, while I have seen cardinals at feeders well after dark, with Brown Thrashers, and Grey Catbirds also remaining active shortly after dark. In general, expect cardinals to visit every day with at least several pairs plus fledglings visiting from April to September, while during the winter, up to 25-30 birds may come if there is enough food or a lot of people with bird tables. 


Male House Finch, Wilmington Garden, 2011-2012


Finches and Buntings: Most of the seed eating birds that come to bird tables are finches or buntings. Both categories of birds are small with blunt or stubby bills, upright postures, and exhibit typical songbird habits. All finches and buntings remain still while feeding and may stay on a feeder for minutes at a time. House Finches, American Goldfinches, and Siskins are gregarious and active with entire feeding stations being taken over when they arrive, while the larger Purple Finch is a sluggish bird that may remain on a feeder for 20-30 minutes and are solitary or in pairs. During the spring, summer, and early autumn, Indigo Buntings, Blue Grosbeaks, and Painted Buntings visit feeders and exhibit the same habits as House Finches or Purple Finches. They may remain in place for minutes at a time and visit frequently throughout the day if they breed nearby. Most finches will feed on the ground, on open trays, or hanging feeders, but generally do not hang upside down (except Goldfinches and Siskins). In general, can identify finches and buntings by their color patterns, beaks, and size. Goldfinches and Siskins are tiny (about 10-12cm or 4-4.5" long), while Purple Finches and Blue Grosbeaks are approaching the size of a Downy Woodpecker (about 16cm, 6.5"). The other species fall in between. Male finches and buntings are brightly colored and can be identified with any guide or search. Goldfinches are yellow and always come in groups, Painted Buntings are multicolored (with the females greenish), House Finches and Purple Finches both have red or magenta heads/chests (respectively), and lastly, male Indigo Buntings are solid blue in the summer. Male House Sparrows can identified by their reddish brown backs, black chests, and white undersides, while females look similar to our native sparrows or the Indigo Bunting. Like the other finches House Sparrows come in groups and visit feeders, bird tables or on the ground but tend to be more energetic and are very aggressive. This bird is mainly found around farmyards, cereal fields (wheat, sorghum, millet etc) urban areas, and older apartment complexes or homesites, and rarely go far from human settlement. The females of all "finches" are generally brown or grey with varying color patterns, but they can be narrowed down by looking at their male counterparts. Because of their sedentary habits you have a lot of time to observe and watch finches or buntings as they feed. 


Song Sparrow, Townhome Bird Table, Autumn 2020


Ground Sparrows: Sparrows generally visit bird tables during the autumn and winter though Song, Chipping, and Field Sparrows may visit at anytime. With the exception of the Chipping Sparrow, all species feed on or near the ground and are more energetic than finches or buntings. They run or hop back and forth on the ground picking up fallen seeds, or may jump onto bird tables or tray feeders. House Sparrows (which aren't sparrows) behave more like the other finches and will come up to elevated feeders. All sparrows generally eat small seeds and will come in mixed flocks ranging from 10-50 individuals. In the Carolinas, you often see White-Throated, White-Crowned, Song, and Field Sparrows around bird tables or in flowerbeds and hedges as well as the larger Fox Sparrow and Eastern Towhee. All of the Hedge Sparrows exhibit complex social behaviors like chickadees and remain loyal to gardens with reliable food, with the same groups arriving each autumn and staying until they return to the boreal or arctic region to breed (except Towhees, Song or Field Sparrows which do not migrate long distances). Chipping Sparrows behave more like finches and may sit still on seed feeders for minutes at a time or feed on seeds on the ground and come in flocks of 15 to nearly 100 birds during the autumn or winter but are highly nomadic and will move on eventually. Juncos feed like Chipping Sparrows. 


Blue Jay at Window Feeder, Townhome Bird Table, Spring 2020

Blue Jay: Blue Jays are common bird table visitors in wooded neighborhoods, gardens or homesites within oak, hickory, or beech forests, and near urban parks. They are the only corvid that regularly visits bird tables although Fish Crows may come to feeders in urban areas. These birds are easily recognized by their large size (about 30cm or 12" long), and are the only blue and white birds with crests in the Carolinas (the Kingfisher looks like a jaybird but has a long spear-like bill and dives into ponds for fish). Blue Jays have interesting habits and routines and tend to visit bird tables or feeders at specific times and are highly seasonal. In my experiences, I found jays to come early in the morning (between 7-9am) from mid-autumn (after the oaks have finished producing acorns), until about February, while in other areas, Blue Jays may come all day or only in the afternoon. Jays have large territories and remain in family groups or flocks up to 30 individuals and tend to follow distinct paths through the woodlands and suburbs. Jays are aggressive and will dominate birdfeeders or tables, and come in pairs or small groups with the others waiting their turns in the trees. Like their smaller woodland counterparts like chickadees and titmice, Jays generally carry off nuts (including whole peanuts, pecans, or walnuts), seeds, or suet chunks to cache in nooks or bash open in treetops. Despite their size, they are agile enough to hang from suet feeders, and at my current townhome residence, Jays have learned to hang off my window feeder and make less noise than the Red-Bellied Woodpecker, or Common Starlings which are smaller but heavier. Jays are very noisy, mean, and are difficult to ignore, but along with crows, ravens, and parrots, they are among the most intelligent birds in the world and may use tools. 


Mockingbird on Lard Feeder, Wilmington Garden Spring 2010

Mockingbirds: Mockingbirds are common bird table visitors in the Carolinas and will come if there is mealworms, suet, or other soft foods available and can become a menace. They generally remain solitary and stay on their territories year-round. Mockingbirds can hang from suet cages, hover, and will feed on peanuts, or no-mess seed mixes readily. If you see a grey long-tailed songbird that perches upright or has white wing bars, it is probably a mockingbird. They generally remain near the feeder when they are not eating and may perch on powerlines, trees, fences, or your roof, and visit frequently throughout the day (especially during the winter or when they are feeding young). Mockingbirds chase off all other birds and are one of the few birds that will readily nest near a feeding station if there are shrubs or vine tables nearby, effectively rendering the feeder useless. In most cases there is only one or two mockingbirds per feeder, and they may leave a feeder for days or weeks at a time when nesting or if natural fruits (hollies, privets, hackberry, hawthorn etc) become ripe. 


Brown Thrasher, Wilmington Garden/Backyard Habitat 1A, 2010


Brown Thrasher: The Thrasher is generally largest bird that regularly visits bird tables and is easily identified by its very long tail, plump body, long, slightly curved bill, and its reddish brown body with a white underside and streaks. The Wood Thrush is similar except much smaller and shorter-billed. Thrashers live year-round in wooded gardens, rural properties, and on the edges of woodlands, riparian groves, hedgerows, or overgrown pastures but can be found in urban landscapes with establish shrubs (like azalea, privet, or yew). They feed mostly on the ground and will eat almost anything (seeds, insects, snails, fruits, small vertebrates, food scraps etc). Brown Thrashers will visit ground feeders or low bird tables for seeds, corn, nuts, or come to suet feeders and will become faithful visitors once they discover your setup. They can be aggressive but generally carry off food items to bash open on rocks, and do not chase off other birds like mockingbirds. Some thrashers will even try to visit window feeders (I have a pair on a hanging tray for mealworms and suet chunks), and are quite agile despite their large size, cumbersome and heavy appearance. Thrashers can be in pairs, or small loose flocks and will become so tame that they will fly or run up to people if they associate them with food (almost like Boat Tailed Grackles at parking lots, or House Sparrows in urban centers).


Carolina Wren, Townhome Bird Table, 2018

Carolina Wren: The Carolina Wren is another unusual and somewhat distinctive visitor who will become a daily visitor to your feeder if suet, mealworms, shell-less seed mixes, or peanuts are offered. They are sparrow-sized birds about 15-17 cm (6-7") long with long bills, and a tail that is often pointed upward. Unlike other small birds, they are orange and yellow with white eyebrows and sing a loud song (a chanting series) throughout the year. Wrens are energetic and loyal and will visit multiple times per day, and always come in pairs except when young are present. They creep like nuthatches or treecreepers, and will feed on the ground, on hanging feeders, and readily approach people they trust. I consider wrens to be the ideal feeder birds as they are peaceful, will accept a wide range of foods, and are almost as colorful as warblers, or buntings. They carry off seeds, nuts, or food chunks like nuthatches but will hammer them open against stones, masonry, logs, or metal fences (they open snails, cicadas, and other tough prey in the same manner). Wrens will also nest near homes in wooded neighborhoods or if your garden has established plantings. The tiny Winter Wren (about 8-10cm or 3-4") is dark brown or blackish and has a tiny bill and may feed on suet crumbs under feeders in the winter, while the House Wren is similar except lighter, and with a longer tail (making them closer to 10cm or 4"), and may also try suet or peanut butter. These wrens are never far from the ground and are generally occasional visitors during the autumn or when inclement weather (like a snow or ice event) occurs. 


Adult and Fledgling Starlings on suet, Townhome Bird Table, Summer 2021


Common Starling: I consider starlings to be occasional or specialized visitors that may come to bird tables for soft foods like suet, lard, bread, mealworms, or occasionally peanuts, and are highly seasonal. These birds have a nasty reputation and are nonnative like the House Sparrow, but my experiences with starlings have been positive. These birds may compete with cavity nesters but they generally nest in pairs (rather than in colonies like House Sparrows), and most native birds can fend them off or live in cavities too small for starlings. Second, it is rare for more than a few starlings to visit a household bird table and these birds are not as aggressive as mockingbirds, grackles, or even Blue Jays but can still be intimating with their long bills and large size. At my previous homesite (my mother's home), Common Starlings came only for suet or lard and were generally spring visitors (right before nesting), or sometimes came during migration with blackbirds. At my current place, there is a starling population that nests in the awnings of our building with a few pairs visiting from late February through September, with fledglings arriving in June after their single brood is finished (one or two birds may remain in the winter). In general, starlings remain still while feeding, can hang sideways or upside down, and will fight others of their own species if they get too close (even their own partners or brood). They rarely attack other birds and generally lose to Red-Bellied Woodpeckers, Northern Mockingbird, or Brown Thrashers, while chickadees, wrens, nuthatches, and even Downy Woodpeckers can feed alongside them. They will feed on the ground. From my observations, starlings tend to visit earlier in the day except when nesting is in progress (in which case they come throughout the day), and will only show up if suet, mealworms, or soft foods are out (my birds can even recognize the blue tray feeder or yellow suet cage). In general, you will get one pair per feeder unless your feeders are spread out, and the birds seen in the winter are likely migrants as there is a gap between July and September when no starlings are present (though flocks will fly overhead). 


Pine Warbler, Townhome Garden, Winter 2020

Pine Warbler: The Pine Warbler is a common feeder visitor in areas with lots of pine trees and in Coastal Carolina, they are abundant in suburbs, cities, and rural areas, and love neighborhoods and golf courses with scattered pines. They are the only Parulidae Warbler that visits seed feeders and one or four species that will come to bird tables on a regular basis and is a year-round resident in most places. They eat seeds, peanuts, mealworms, and suet and generally remain still while feeding, but will carry off seeds to eat or store. This warbler and the Black and White, and Yellow Throated Warbler will creep like nuthatches or hang upside down. Adults are about 15cm or 6" long, have thicker bills, and are yellow like goldfinches, except with streaks. Pine Warblers will regularly come in pairs or small groups and are generally docile and approachable. I had Pine Warblers come to my hand and they often hang out with chickadees, titmice, or Chipping Sparrows. The Yellow Throated Warbler may also come to feeders and will visit during the summer months. Myrtle Warbler visits in flocks from November to April and eat seeds, suet, and breadcrumbs. This warbler looks like the Pine Siskin except with a thin bill, and will chase off other birds and are practically fearless of people. As their name implies, this warbler consumes the fruits of Wax Myrtle and Bayberry. Other warblers may visit suet, mealworm, or nectar feeders during the summer or early autumn and generally mix with chickadees and other songbirds.


Mourning Dove, Townhome Garden Spring 2019

Mourning Dove: The Mourning Dove is a regularly visitor to bird tables and gardens throughout the Carolinas and is the only dove likely to be seen in most areas. They forage almost entirely on the ground for plant or grass seeds, fallen tree seeds, and sometimes other items, and live in habitats including forest clearings, heathlands, pastures, farmlands, open countryside, and suburban gardens. At the bird table doves are usually found on the ground under feeders or tables cleaning up fallen seeds dropped by other birds or raiding squirrels. They may also feed on low bird tables, mounted trays, and occasionally hanging tray feeders. In general doves are gentle and will waddle on the ground (often walking in circles or oval patterns) as they graze on seeds. After feeding they fly to a wire, tree, or the hedgerow to rest and digest their meals. Mourning Doves may feed for minutes or even up to an hour at a time and from my observations, they tend to come at specific times (first thing in the morning, midday, and again in the evening). They are skittish and will flush if approached, or startled, with their wings making a loud whistling noise. This bird also avoids areas with tall vegetation. During the winter, Mourning Doves form flocks that roam the countryside with rural bird tables hosting dozens or even more than a hundred birds at a time, while 15-20 birds is not uncommon in a typical suburban or urban setup with millet, sorghum, or sunflower seeds. The Common Ground Dove is a small dove that is about half the size of a Mourning Dove (about 14-15cm 5.5-6"), but is similar in color and is found from Southeastern NC southward. This dove exhibits similar behaviors to the Mourning Dove but is less skittish and may fly up to tray or hopper feeders. The Collared Dove or Turtle Dove is also found mostly in the southern region of the Carolinas (from about Wilmington southward) and is essentially the same as the Mourning Dove except for its whitish or ivory coloration and black collar. These may visit bird tables and occasionally hanging feeders in wooded urban areas or around dooryards, often amongst Mourning Dove. The Rock Dove or pigeon is found mainly in urban areas and from my experiences is a rare visitor in most suburban or even inner city neighborhoods (I have only seen lone birds occasionally at my mother's place), though I have seen them swamp setups near shopping centers or in bigger cities like Boston. They exhibit the same behavior as Mourning Doves but come in various color patterns. 


Baltimore Oriole, Townhome Garden, Winter-Spring 2018

Orioles: Baltimore Orioles may visit bird tables during the autumn and winter in the Carolinas and are quite common in the coastal regions from October to April. They typically come for nectar, sugar water (including in hummingbird feeders), fruits, or grape jelly, but I have more experience in birds eating no-mess seed mixes, peanut halves, suet, mealworms, while jelly often gave me ants or yellowjackets. Orioles are breathtaking birds with males bring one of the few orange and black birds in the area, while females and juveniles are yellow or gold. All birds have long spear-like bills, long tails, and are about 16-17cm (6.5-7") long, or just about the size a Starling. Orioles are very tame and will approach people that feed them (even coming to the hand), wait in shrubs or trees for someone to put out their meals. They can be very aggressive and will chase off other birds like Cardinals, Grey Catbirds, and Starlings, but placing sweet items in another area should reduce conflicts. Expect anywhere from two to ten or more birds the visit your garden from autumn through spring, especially if there are winter flowering plants like Camellias, Forsythia, Carolina Cherry Laurel, or Coral Honeysuckle in the area. During the summer the smaller Orchard Oriole resides in the Carolinas and also nests in rural, suburban, and urban with scattered trees. Adults are about 15cm (6") long and have a finchlike song (comparable to a House Finch or Indigo Bunting, except more erratic). They will eat the same things at bird tables although I have not had luck bringing Orchard Orioles to bird tables even though they were abundant in both places. 


Ruby-Throated Hummingbird, Wilmington Garden, 2013


Hummingbirds: Hummingbirds can be attracted to bird tables with nectar or sugar water feeders and are generally present from March to October, although along the coast, they can be seen through the winter. The Ruby-Throated Hummingbird is the only breeding species and is common in most areas and is often seen in the winter in Eastern North or South Carolina, while the Rufous Hummingbird is an uncommon autumn and winter visitor. Both species are small birds (around 10-11cm 4-4.25" long) that hover, zip around at speeds up to 96kmh (60mph) and are the only birds that can fly backwards. Adults are greenish with white (or for Rufous rusty) undersides, and long, thin bills, while the male Ruby-Throat has a reddish throat that may or may not be visible. If you have nectar feeders, you can expect one or several hummingbirds to visit daily, although some people have hosted dozens of Ruby-Throat or Rufous Hummingbirds if they have multiple feeders spaced out. They can be one of the most aggressive birds in the gardens with both genders harassing chickadees, titmice, wrens, sparrows, and even birds as large as Brown Thrashers and Blue Jays. They will even chase bumblebees paper wasps, and hornets from flowers and dive at pets and people. If your feeder is too close to the bird table or seed feeder, a hummingbird may prevent the other birds from using it. These birds visit feeders briefly before dashing off into the wood (where they nest in trees near creeks or lakes), to the next flower patch or meadow to feed. However, hummingbirds need to feed constantly and will come and go throughout the day, while males may use feeders or flowerbeds as courtship sites and perform aerial displays for passing females. From my observations and notes, I found hummingbirds (both species) to visit gardens or feeders most frequently from August to November (with September and early October being peak season), while visits drop off during the nesting season in May-June. During the winter, most gardens have just one or two hummingbirds and only if there are winter flowers such as Coral Honeysuckle, Cherry Laurel, or Camellia, citruses, (or any tropical plant that can survive mild winters in Coastal South Carolina). 


Grey Squirrel, Wilmington Garden, 2019

Tree Squirrels: Any bird table or feeder that is placed within or near woodlands or large trees will eventually attract squirrels. Grey Squirrels and the larger Fox Squirrel are considered nuisances at bird tables as they can wipe out supplies from open tables or trays, find their way onto hanging feeders, and can potentially destroy equipment. Even squirrel proof feeders can be defeated if they are too close to branches, awnings, or too low to the ground though cage feeders work better. Most people, including myself prefer not to encourage squirrels while others feed squirrels peanuts, corn, or even specially made squirrel mixes. Regardless of the problems they cause, and not to mention the fact that they dig up garden bulbs, eat garden vegetables, and occasionally eat young birds in open nests or birdhouses (especially those for Starlings, Common Flickers, Crested Flycatchers and other mid-sized birds), squirrels exhibit some interesting behaviors and are fun to watch. Grey Squirrels are common in most deciduous or mixed forests in the Carolinas and are present in any suburban or urban neighborhood with oaks, hickories, beeches, or pines, while the Fox Squirrel lives in more open spaces such as pinelands, pine-oak barrens, sparsely planted suburbs, and urban parks but use the same types of trees. In general, Greys need more trees and are more adaptable in urban settings, while Foxes like the open countryside and dry sandy areas with scattered trees. Both squirrels will visit bird tables daily but like Blue Jays they tend to come at specific times and are creatures of habits. I found Grey Squirrels to visit my gardens in the midmorning or sometimes in the afternoon, with each family group coming from a different route. If you watch squirrels closely, you will notice that they follow the same routes with some animals running along fences or using hedgerows, while others come straight down trees, or run across lawns or streets. Squirrels will also fight just like birds with rival families chasing each other up trees, making chucking noises, and occasionally wrestling on the ground. Other behaviors include an increase in seed or nut hoarding during the autumn and winter (Most of the lost birdseed, peanuts, and nuts are buried in the ground for the winter), courtship. Grey Squirrels also serve as sentinels and make whining noises when a hawk, cat, or snake is in the area and respond to warning calls from jays, chickadee/titmice, wrens, and their smaller cousins the Chipmunk. In general, you can expect anywhere from 5-20 Grey Squirrels at a time at a feeder station, while Fox Squirrels are generally solitary or in pairs but eat more food in one sitting.


Woodrat, Townhome Garden, Summer 2021


Mice and Rats: During the autumn and winter, your bird tables may be visited by smaller rodents including one of the several species of mice or rats. In general small rodents are occasional visitors and are generally nocturnal, meaning if you take in your feeders, they will not become a problem. Most of the time mice and rats do not cause problems with properly managed feeding stations unless you put out too much food or have feeders that are poorly placed. Like squirrels, mice and rats also have interesting behaviors and habits. Most gardens are visited by native rodent species including the Field Mouse, White-Footed or Deer Mouse (in more wooded areas), Woodrats (aka Packrats), and in coastal regions of Carolina, Rice and Marsh Rats. With the exception of the White-Footed Mouse and Woodrat, most of these rodents do not infest homes and all rodents can be kept out with proper maintenance and sanitation (a subject for another article). Gardens may also host the nonnative House Mouse, and Roof Rat which may become problems near farms or in urban areas, but are generally an occasional pest in suburbia. The giant Norway or Brown Rat is not common at all in suburban settings but may be found in larger cities, near seaports, industrial sites, and farms. All of these rodents may visit feeders for sunflower seeds, safflower, millet, corn, or cereal grains, while both Woodrats and Roof Rats seem to love suet and lard. Like squirrels, outdoor mice and rats follow specific routes through meadows, woodlands, or neighborhoods and use tunnels, runways (paths made in grass or marshlands), fences, wires, and trees to navigate and avoid hawks, owls, and foxes. Individuals or groups visit at specific times with nocturnal visitor generally coming shortly after sunset or in the predawn hours, less so in the middle of the night. Packrats, Roof Rats, and especially Field or Deer Mice will visit in broad daylight and behave more like squirrels. However, these rodents will avoid open spaces, and scurry away when approached, while the  squirrels always win against their smaller counterparts. Other smaller rodents that may visit bird tables include Chipmunks which are the same size as Roof Rats but are gregarious, diurnal, and make piping noises. These rodents can be destructive and are harder than squirrels to deter but have complex social structures and always hibernate in the winter. Marmots also known as "Groundhogs" or Woodchucks are also present in most areas and may occasionally come to feeders, while Cottontail Rabbits (not a rodent) have also come to ground feeders on occasion. In general all of these animals should not be a problem at a properly managed bird table and are good opportunities to learn about the food web and the local ecosystem.   


Cooper's Hawk, Winston Salem, September 2018


Birds of Prey: Birds of Prey are occasional visitors to bird tables throughout the year with at least four species of hawks being common around gardens and suburbs throughout the year. When a hawk or owl swoops down near your birdfeeder, it can bring a mix of excitement, disbelief, and concern. While seeing an apex predator like a Red Tailed Hawk, or a Great Horned Owl can be exciting, they can quickly wear out their welcome if they become regular visitors. Both birds mainly go after rodents, and small mammals and may actually be an benefit as squirrels and diurnal mice/rats will become more cautious and may avoid the area for some time. However, sparrowhawk species such as Cooper and Sharp-Shinned Hawks can become pests as they hunt almost exclusively birds and are attracted to bird tables and other areas where birds congregate. The Cooper's Hawk (the main species that lives in our area), is right at home in urban and suburban areas, and will also nest in wooded neighborhoods. The Sharp-Shinned Hawk is more of a winter visitor and is smaller, more agile, and can even catch birds as small as chickadees or warblers, but tend to remain in the countryside and are displaced by the Cooper's Hawk. The other hawks including the Red-Shouldered and Broad Winged Hawk are primarily after other animals or larger birds and stick to forested areas. While hawks visit for only a brief time, you can learn a lot about their lifecycle by watching the skies over your neighborhood. With time, you will notice that some species of hawk or owl are more prevalent than others depending on the landscape, and that all birds follow a particular schedule, take consistent paths, and have preferred perches. In open or urbanized areas, you may notice that Red-Tailed Hawks soar overhead during the midday, rest on fences, rooftops, or tall trees, and frequent areas with consistent prey. Some Redtails prefer squirrels and have learned to knock dreys (squirrel dens) from trees, or chase them when they cross lawns, or climb up a tree, while others prefer rabbits, field mice, rats, and occasionally geese. Red Shouldered Hawks are very vocal and remain within the forest but venture into suburbs and perhaps to bird tables to snap up squirrels or occasionally a Mourning Dove, while both Great-Horned and Barred Owls will hunt in broad daylight when they are feeding young, and may also come to a garden. As for the Sparrowhawks, they lurk in dense shrubs or trees like "winged cats" and wait for a bird to land before attacking. Cooper's Hawks and "Sharpies" fly in a straight path like a cruise missile and remain low to the ground or treeline before surprising their prey. These hawks will also run after wounded prey, go into hedges, and raid nests. Cooper's Hawks are not afraid of people at all and will buzz low overhead at speeds over 96kmh (60mph), come up to buildings, and may attack you if you disturb their nest. Falcons such as Peregrines and Merlins occasionally visit feeders but always attack from above and rarely stay in one are for long. While watching one of the Sparrowhawks kill your songbirds can be disturbing, we have to remember that the predators are part of the ecosystem, and most birds can evade or even attack predators. For instance, titmice, chickadees, thrushes (Wood, Veery, Hermit, Swainson's and American Robin) Kinglets, and Treecreepers have specific high-pitched calls for Accipiter Sparrowhawks or falcons, while Common Starlings and Red-Winged Blackbirds both have chattering calls for hawks. These calls trigger all other birds and often nearby mammals to seek shelter or initiate mobbing behaviors, which can be just as fascinating as seeing an apex predator in action.  


24 March, 2021

Spring Arrivals

Spring Arrivals  


Red Winged Blackbird "Redwing" amongst Bald Cypresses in spring


Spring in the Carolinas comes well before the equinox. Some native or cultivated plants such as Jessermine, Redbud, and Japanese Cherries bloom as early as February. Honeybees, Carpenter Bees, Paper Wasps, and Sulphur Butterflies come out when every it is warm (i.e., about 10-15 Celsius or 50-60F) with ample sunlight. Finally, many birds begin singing, courtship, and even nesting in what would be considered midwinter. Spring Migration in our region can begin as early as Mid-February and typically ends in late May when most of the breeding birds are onsite and transients have come and gone. This document is a timetable and overview of how spring migration works in the Cape Fear Region and Southeastern North Carolina. The timings of arrivals and departures, as well as what species can be seen will differ slightly in South Carolina, Appalachia, the Northeast of Carolina (like the Outer Banks), etc. 


Observations of Spring 


Our meadow garden in late April 2016, Blue Flag Iris on left, Siberian Iris on Right


For nearly a year since the pandemic began, I walked around Greenfield Lake in Wilmington NC two or three times of week to observe the wildlife, plant life, and environment for personal studies, and the collect data for a project at the university. I saw this park during the late winter (March 18th, 2020), with the trees bare, violets blooming in the woodlands, and azaleas starting to blossom, for an Azalea Festival that did not occur. From there, I saw the park and lakeshore through the spring, the Carolinian Summer, our long autumn, and through the dead of winter. Because of my life and my tendency to visit different parks, woodlands, and the seacoast, I have never gotten a chance to observe an area for an entire year with regular visits (excluding my own garden of course). At the time of writing this, Greenfield was at the start of another spring cycle. 

Sounds of Spring: In the Southeast of North Carolina, I begin noticing birdsong around Christmastime. Resident Carolina Wrens, Cardinals, Carolina Chickadees, Tufted Titmice, and Pine Warblers sing before the winter solstice even arrives. Brown Thrashers, Mockingbirds, Song Sparrows, and even wintering Hermit Thrushes also sing on warmer days. The sound begins to pick up from late January through March with the early singers becoming more vocal, and other resident or even wintering birds adding to the chorus. 

Each morning I open my window of my townhome's upstairs bedroom to hear the chorus and symphony, even if I still have jazz or classical music playing in my room (which I often do at night or while writing). From as early as five in the morning, I may hear the wrens giving their chants "Teacher Teacher Teacher" or "Teakettle Teakettle Teakettle" from the hedge or atop wall separating our dooryard from the common areas. Then I hear the beautiful whistling song of chickadees which have three to six syllables (some song sound like "Spring is Here"). After that, the Cardinals, Mockingbirds, Brown Thrashers, Chipping Sparrows, Pine Warblers, Starlings, and Eastern Bluebirds chime in, while sounds of Canada Geese, Ospreys, Bald Eagle, and Red Shouldered Hawks can be heard from the lake. A Barred Owl or Great Horned Owl may even sing during the chorus with the birds hardly concerned at all. As the season goes on, new voices are added to the chorus, with the Yellow Throated Warbler being among the first spring arrivals in Wilmington NC, followed shortly by the Parula, and preceded (by two-weeks) by the Gnatcatcher. Meanwhile winter residents like the Eastern Phoebes the lives in the neighborhood behind us, very loud Ruby Crowned Kinglet (for a bird only 9-10cm/3.5-4" in size) or White Throated Sparrow's singsongy whistle that is written as "Old Sam Peabody Peabody". 

Visions of Spring: Late winter and spring is an exciting time to observe birds and wildlife as well. In my garden, it seemed like all of the birds came to life overnight sometime in Mid-February (like the 15th or 16th of February). Mockingbirds started chasing each other in the hedge and around the parking lots, Brown Thrashers sung loudly from treetops, and flocks of American Robins, Redwings, Grackles, Starlings, and Cowbirds flew high overhead in a northward. The wrens and chickadees are already looking for crevices, unattended objects, or tree holes to nest in, while the breeding pairs of Starlings returned from migration in Late February (with a noticeable gap between the massive wintering flocks of blackbirds, robins, starlings, and waxwings that descended on the hollies and cherry laurels in January). 


At Greenfield Lake I saw massive flocks Canada Geese thin out as the birds paired off and males defended potental nest sites amongst hedges, coppices, or on treed islands near the lakes. On the third week of March (around the 20th of March), I came across a massive flock of martins and swallows circling over the lake. There were hundreds of birds (I entered 100+ on eBird) with most of them being Tree Swallows stopping for a drink and feed on swarms of midges as the head north. Groups of Purple Martins were mixed in, while I also looked for Sand Martins, Rough Winged Swallows, Barn Swallows, and Cliff Swallows, which often mix in with Tree Swallows. The massive swallow flocks was what I called the start of spring migration, and on the next day, I saw a mass of swallows over my townhome (sometimes flying just above the rooftops). Like at the lake, there were Tree Swallows, and Purple Martins, but I also confirmed my first Barn Swallow (about 1-2 weeks early), and possibly some Sand Martins or even a Chimney Swift. These observations came with other spring behaviors such as cardinals fighting over territories, Ospreys and Eagles doing courtship displays, and massive brawls between the resident Red Shouldered Hawks (and occasionally visiting Red Tailed Hawks) over feeding areas. Before long, the lakefront will be alive with activity again as spring migration kicks in. I can't wait until the Grey Catbirds, Orchard Orioles, Red Eyed Vireos, Mississippi Kites, and other summer residents arrive and for the Common Grackles and Redwing colonies to fill in the trees and marshes along the lakeshore. 

Author Update: On the 22nd of March, 2020, I saw and photographed a Chimney Swift at Greenfield Lake that arrived two weeks earlier than expected. It was amongst a similar flock of swallows and martins. 


About Spring Migration

Spring Migration is an exciting time for many birdwatchers and casual bird lovers, particularly those further north where most of the birds migrate south. In these regions the behaviors mentioned in the stories above, begin later in spring. The Carolinas are under a major migration corridor for songbirds, waterfowl, and birds of prey, although unlike the Autumn Migration Cycle most of the traffic is funnelled along the Appalachian Mountains in Western NC, SC, and into Tennessee. Along the Carolina Coast, Spring Migration is mediocre with most of the traffic consisting of widespread species heading north, or inbound breeding species. We miss out on all of the warblers, vireos, and other songbirds as they move through the highlands, and most hawks also travel inland. While Spring Migration is disappointing in the Cape Fear Region, it is not without its joys. Almost every species of bird that passes through a garden or woodland is singing, we wait eagerly for our favorite summer residents to return, and savor every moment we can with our beloved winter residents before they leave us. At the sea, and along the river systems, things are a bit more exciting, as most shorebirds, seabirds, and water birds travel along our coast. Huge flocks of plovers and sandpipers descend on beaches and mudflats with contain dozens of species. Seagulls, terns, loons, and even seafaring species like Shearwaters fly along our beaches. Wading birds like ibis gather at their nest sites to breed, like the Ibis on the island near Southport NC. Spring Migration is a rather long period for us as it begins in late February when Gnatcatchers and Purple Martins come through, and continues through Mid-May when birds like Orchard Orioles, Kites, and Grey Catbirds are on site, and the last of our winter birds have left. 

Hint: Songbirds often gather around trees that are leafing out or blossoming, so you may see waves of migrants as the canopy fills in. For example Oaks, Elms, and Maples leaf in early, while Hickories and Baldcypress are later. 

Arrivals 


Black and White Warblers arrive well before other spring breeders as they forage on trunks


Black and White Warbler: Often in January, though some birds overwinter too

Blue Grey Gnatcatcher: Can arrive as early as second week of February 

Purple Martin: Often the second week of February

Common Starling: Second week of February (breeding males) 

Laughing Gull: Final week of February or first week of March (some overwinter)

Common Yellowthroat: First week of March (some ovewinter)

Redwing (Red Winged Blackbird): First or second week of March (breeding males)

Ruby Throated Hummingbird: Second week of March (many overwinter)

Yellow Throated Warbler: Usually around the second week of March (some overwinter as well)

Parula: Second or third week of March 

Common Grackle: Third week of March (breeding population)

American Robin: Third week of March (summer population)

White Eyed Vireo: Third or fourth week of March (some overwinter)

Prairie Warbler: Third or fourth week of March 

Whippoorwill: Third or fourth week of March

Barn Swallow/Cliff Swallow: Fourth week of March or first week of April

Yellow Throated Vireo: Fourth week of March or first week of April 

Least Tern: First week of April 

Brown Headed Cowbird: First week of April (breeders)

Sand Martin/Rough Winged Swallow: First week of April

Protonotary Warbler: First week of April 

Red Eyed Vireo: First week of April 

Wood Pewee: First week of April 

Ovenbird: First or second week of April

Acadian Flycatcher: First or second week of April

Crested Flycatcher: First or second week of April 

Chimney Swift: Second week of April 

Indigo Bunting: Second week of April 

Painted Bunting: Second week of April (many overwinter)

Wood Thrush: Second week of April

Black Skimmer: Third week of April

Grey Catbird: Third week of April (some overwinter)

Summer Tanager: Third or fourth week of April (some overwinter)

Yellow Billed Cuckoo: Fourth week of April

Common Nighthawk: Fourth week of April 

Chuck-Wills-Widow: Fourth week of April, first week of May 

Blue Grosbeak: Fourth week of April, first week of May

Orchard Oriole: First week of May 

Green Heron: First week of May 


Departures 


Common Flickers are primarily winter residents in Southeastern NC


Wintering Egrets and Herons: Late February 

Most Waterfowl: Early March

Fox Sparrows: Often Early March

Wintering Robins: Mid-Late March for wintering birds

Mallard: Mid-Late March 

Treecreeper: Mid-March

Purple Finch: Late March

Rusty Blackbird: Late March 

Orange-Crowned Warbler: Late March

House Wren and Winter Wren: Late March or Early April

Yellow Bellied Sapsucker: First week of April

Golden Crowned Kinglet: First or second week of April 

Palm Warbler: First or second week of April

Junco: Second week of April 

Eastern Phoebe: Second week of April 

Common Flicker: Second week of April 

Hermit Thrush: Second or third week of April

Baltimore Oriole: Third week of April (some may stay all summer) 

White Throated/Crowned Sparrows: Fourth week of April or first week of May 

Song Sparrow: Early May (though some could linger)

Chipping Sparrow: First week of May (breeders remain in pinewoods and open areas)

Ruby Crowned Kinglet: First week of May

Myrtle Warbler (Yellow Rumped Warbler): First or second week of May

American Goldfinch and Siskin: First or Second week of May (some linger into summer)

Cedar Waxwing: As late as early June (some linger into summer) 


Migrants 


A shot of a Rose Breasted Grosbeak in our back garden in April 2016,. This is one of the latest birds to pass through New Hanover County during spring migration.

Louisiana Waterthrush: Mid-March to Mid-April

Black Throated Green Warbler: Mid-March to Mid-April

Northern Waterthrush: Late March to Mid-April

Yellow Warbler: Late-March to Mid-April 

American Redstart: April to May 

House Wren: April to May 

Scarlet Tanager: April to May 

Veery Thrush: April to May

Rose Breasted Grosbeak Late April to Late May 

Blackburnian Warbler: May to June 

Blackpoll Warbler: May to June 



21 October, 2020

Woodland Bird Flocks

Woodland Flocks


A large flock of Fish Crows (at least 200), a single-species flock


Flocks are groups of birds that remain together as they forage or travel. While flocking is a behavior associated with migration, it is exhibited year round by many species of birds. Most flocks consist of just one species of bird, although it is common for multiple species to form an association with each other. This is known as as a mixed flock, mixed guild, or even a bird wave depending on the literature. Mixed flocks are commonly seen with shorebirds, seagulls, and most of the smaller bird species such as songbirds or woodpeckers. In the breeding season, mixed species aggregations may be associated with nest colonies such as how terns, shorebirds, seagulls, and in the northern regions of Europe and North American, Auks share on nest area. Swallow species such as the colonial Sand Martin (or Bank Swallow), and the more solitary Rough Winged Swallow may associate with each other when nesting in riverbanks (a habitat that is limited in distribution). Mixed flocks are primarily  seen during the nonbreeding season when food is less abundant and birds are no longer defending nesting territories or raising young.

In the Carolinas, the most common types of mixed flocks include those made up of woodland birds, blackbirds and starlings, fruit eating birds (frugivorous) like waxwings or thrushes, and seed eating birds (sparrows, finches etc). These flocks are a good opportunity to see different bird species in the field or around the garden. A group mostly made up of common species like chickadees might contain migratory warblers or vireos during the autumn, different woodpeckers, or even a rare visitor. Take a close look at any group of songbirds from late summer through spring as you might be surprised what could waiting around the corner

Autumn and Winter Flocks


Chickadee with oriole in background, a winter flock. There were a dozen or more birds in this grouping during this December morning in 2018.



Mixed feeding flocks are most likely to be encountered from the mid-summer (as early as July) through early spring (April) when most birds are not defending breeding territories. During these seasons songbirds and other birds will follow chickadees, titmice, or other resident birds as they forage, roost, or migrate southward. You will also see this with seagulls, sandpipers and plovers, as well as other types of songbirds. The woodland bird flocks are interesting because they can contain dozens of species of birds, and can benefit individuals that associate with them. These flocks also have an establish social and hierarchal structure and are an example of complex social behavior that is exhibited in many intelligent species. 

Role: The role of mixed feeding flocks in woodland or meadowland species is still being studied although there are several theories on their purpose. The most common theory is that mixed flocks can offer more protection to birds and increase their productivity during times of scarcity. This means more eyes and ears to detect potential threats such as predators, and an increased likelihood that the birds will find food and water. In the case of woodland birds, chickadees and other birds will sound an alarm if a hawk, cat, or snake is in the area, causing the other birds to take cover or begin mobbing. These benefits extend beyond the flock as mobbing birds can also alert other species of bird, as well as mammals (squirrels, deer, etc) of a  potential danger.

Structure: While most flocks are just aggregations of birds that form near food or water sources, or at roosts, mixed flocks contain complex social mechanisms to maintain their structure. With woodland birds, chickadees, titmice, or in some cases nuthatches usually lead the flock. These birds are known as a nuclear or nucleus species as they serve as the center or core of the flock. Chickadees, titmice, and Brown Headed Nuthatches maintain complex social hierarchies amongst their own species with dominant individual serving as a leader. The birds that associate with the flock are known as attendants and join the flock only when it enters its territory. Some birds however, will follow the fringes of a flock or switch between multiple flocks in an area. For the purposes of this article I will call these birds followers (to distinguish them from attendants). 

  • Nuclear Species: Carolina Chickadee, Tufted Titmouse, Brown Headed Nuthatch, other species like Pine Warbler
  • Attendants: Birds such as Downy or Hairy Woodpeckers, Carolina Wren,  and White Breasted Nuthatch
  • Followers: Examples include flocks of Eastern Bluebirds or wintering Juncos of Chipping Sparrows, also treecreepers, kinglets, flickers, migrating warblers, vireos, and flycatchers

Nucleus: Titmice and Chickadees typically lead Mixed Flocks


Attendant: Wrens like this House Wren only loosely associate with flocks

Follower: Nuthatches often stay with mixed flocks across multiple teritories  



Niches: Woodland flocks can contain dozens of species of birds that range from mostly terrestrial species like the Ovenbird, Waterthrush, Carolina or Winter Wren, to canopy dwellers like tanagers, vireos, and Crested Flycatchers. During migration or winter, insectivorous birds other gravitate towards resident chickadees, or titmice to find reliable food or safety from predators. In such groups, birds are more likely to find food but there is also the potential of competition. Mixed flocks avoid issues with interspecies competition because most of the birds have different techniques, and diets. Chickadees, titmice, and Pine Warblers are generalists and can feed on a variety of prey as well as seed/fruits on all levels of the forest and its edges. Wrens, sparrows, and thrushes stay near the ground or in the latter case near fruits, while a Wood Pewee or Scarlet Tanager may stick to the treetops to catch insects. 


Pileated Woodpeckers open up food sources for smaller birds


Interspecies Benefits: Some birds such as woodpeckers, or nuthatches can provide opportunities for other birds. When there is a Red Bellied or Pileated Woodpecker with the flock, the other bird species may gain access to food that would be otherwise inaccessible. When one of the woodpeckers drills into a decaying limb for termites, beetles, or ants, smaller woodpeckers like the Downy may come in later to excavate further. Chickadees, titmice, wrens, warblers, and other birds that are unable to excavate into trees will also benefit by eating whatever insects that are exposed or knocked to the ground. Another example of a benefit of mixed flocks can include predator warning. Chickadees, wrens, and jays are very alert and can serve as lookouts for the entire group. If a Sparrowhawk species such as a Cooper's Hawk is detected, chickadees and titmice will produce a high pitched "seeeese" whistle, causing the other birds to freeze or dive for cover. Other calls such as the chickadee's  "Deee deee" call or the scold of wren can trigger mobbing behavior.

Sparrowhawks (Accipiter sp.) are bird specialists, mixed flocks serve as an early warning system for both avian and terrestrial predators. 

  

Range: Most mixed feeding flocks cover a fairly small area although these groups cover more territory than a typical nesting territory. By comparison, nomadic flocks of waxwings, American Robins, blackbirds, and most of the finch or Chipping Sparrow/Junco flocks may cover many miles or travel between abundant food sources. On the other end of the scale, flocks of "Hedge Sparrows" like White Throated, White Crowned, Song, and Fox Sparrows rarely leave stray far from hedgerow or field they are living in (same is true for flocks of cardinals). Chickadees and woodland birds are in the middle as they can cover some great distances within a forest and circulate through dozens of gardens and several bird tables, but rarely travel long distances for food. 

You can learn more about flocking behavior at these two Wikipedia Articles which are a good starting point for beginners (with references at the bottom of each entry). The articles are Mixed Species Flock and Flock.

Finding Woodland Flocks 


This park is ideal habitat for both woodland and meadowland birds


Woodland flocks can be found in almost any forest, woodland, or hedgerow in the Carolinas and most birds that visit your bird table or garden are woodland species. Look or listen for chickadees, titmice, or other recognizable species and keep an eye out for anything different. If chickadees or titmice come to the birdfeeder, look in nearby trees, and shrubs for other birds that may be associated with them. Depending on the season, there may be dozens of songbird species associated with a flock (with some flocks exceeding 100 individuals). These groups are the best way to find autumn or early spring migrants as warblers, vireos, flycatchers, and gnatcatchers usually attend or follow flocks when they are feeding or resting between jumps. Even in the summer, you can still find flocks as chickadees and Brown Headed Nuthatches, immediately reform their flocks after completing their brood, while juvenile and nonbreeding warblers, vireos, and gnatcatchers will stick around woodland birds when they are no longer on their territory. I divide woodland flocks into two categories, the traditional chickadee/titmouse-led guilds, and the flocks made up of pine specialists and birds commonly associated with open areas. I will go into non-woodland flocks in another article as they have similar structures and can lead birders to unusual or unexpected species. 


Kinglets are commonly found in "standard flocks" also look for treecreepers, vireos, and warblers


Standard Woodland Flocks: Flocks that are typically led by chickadees, or titmice and usually contain forest or forest edge species. These are what I consider "traditional" mixed feeding flocks and are the kind that contain nuthatches, woodpeckers, warblers, vireos, treecreepers, and kinglets. Flock make up can differ by habitat, season, or available food sources. 


Pine Warblers may take the place of chickadees as the leader of flocks in pine-dominated landscapes  



Pinewood Flock: A slight variation of the standard flock that may be led by Brown Headed Nuthatches or Pine Warblers, although there are often chickadees as well. These groups may contain the same species as above but frequently include meadowland or open country species such as Common Flickers,  Red Headed Woodpeckers, Chipping Sparrows, Juncos, Goldfinches, Siskins, or House Finches. These groups are often seen in open stands of pines, woodland openings, or in many parks. 

In the Garden

 A garden with trees and shrubs are can to host mixed flocks as well


Woodland flocks often visit adjacent residential areas and chances are there is at least one mixed feeding guild within your neighborhood or in a nearby woodland. While chickadees, titmice, and nuthatches (as well as Red Bellied Woodpeckers) are very adaptable and outgoing, most of the forest species are overlooked because they do not come to bird tables, or gardens. Autumn and winter flocks can bring many opportunities to find shier species of birds, migrating species, and even a rare or vagrant species. Additionally, when flocks of chickadees, or titmice come to the feeder, the rest of the flock is not far behind. 

Attraction: You can attract woodland flocks to your garden by providing food, water, and suitable roosting spots. Any garden or community that has good habitat for chickadees, titmice, woodpeckers, or nuthatches will likely host flocks in the winter. Deciduous trees and shrubs are good for attracting most warblers, vireos, and flycatchers, while evergreens like junipers, hollies, wax myrtle, arborvitae can provide dense cover for roosting birds. Pines are important for many species of birds and are a prerequisite for Brown Headed, or Red Breasted Nuthatches and Pine Warblers. Open areas, flowerbeds, meadows, rain  gardens, and riparian vegetation can add additional habitat for sparrows, buntings, flycatchers, and other species not associated with forests. Really, almost any garden can host woodland flocks with little to no improvement although native plants, winter flowering plants like Camellia (which kinglets, Orange Crowned Warblers and orioles love the nectar from) and fruit bearing plants add to the food value. 

Feeders: Woodland flocks often come to gardens with bird tables and other sources of food. Chickadees, titmice, nuthatches, Pine Warblers, Downy/Hairy Woodpeckers, and Red Bellied Woodpeckers all visit bird tables on a regular basis, often throughout the year. In the autumn and winter, these "ordinary" species come with new surprises. While many of the flock followers will stay in the trees or hedges, some of the bolder species might check out a bird feeder or suet cage, or land on railings or nearby shrubs. Kinglets, many warbler species, and Winter Wrens will sometimes come to porches or dooryards with chickadees, even if they do not use the feeder. During snowy conditions or when it is cold, a treecreeper, Yellow Throated Warbler or someone else might try out suet or mealworms, while the very sight of chickadees and cardinals could draw in a nearby Baltimore Oriole or overwintering tanager. 

Rarities: One of the best things about mixed flocks is the chance that you may get lucky and find something unusual, rare, or out of season. Autumn flocks can bring almost anything imaginable. A cluster full of American Redstarts, Parulas, or Cape May Warblers (not to mention chickadees and titmice) might contain a overlooked or uncommon Nashville or Wilson's Warbler. Overwintering warblers, tanagers, and other summer or transient residents will gravitate towards chickadees in order to survive. A Summer or Western Tanager, or the odd gnatcatcher might spend the winter in a garden or park by staying close to chickadees, cardinals and other gregarious species.   

Other Flocks to Scan: While I will mainly be focusing on woodland flocks in this article, it is still a good idea to investigate any flock of birds that visits your garden or you come across in a woodland, park, or shoreline. 

Flock of shorebirds at Shackleford Banks in 2010, this group has godwits and oystercatchers 

  • A large "swarm" of blackbirds or starlings (typically made up overwhelmingly of wintering Red Winged Blackbirds, Common Grackles and Common Starlings) might contain meadowlarks, Rusty Blackbirds, or a Brewer's Blackbird. 
  • The same is true for the massive flocks of Cedar Waxwings or American Robins that descend on fruit-laden shrubs from December to early March as they begin their slow journey north. 
  • A flock of House Sparrows or native White Throated/Crowned Sparrows could hide a Dickcissel, Bobolink, or Indigo Bunting during migration, or a Fox Sparrow in the winter. 
  • Goldfinch, House Finch and Siskin flocks might include Evening Grosbeaks, Purple Finches or a Crossbill during irruption years (not to mention any combination of escaped finches from captivity). 
  • As a rule, shorebird and seagull flocks never just contain contain Laughing or Ring Billed Gull or Sanderlings/Willets. There could be anything from Iceland Gulls to Golden Plovers mixed in (both vagrants from the Old World), along with more common species. (hence photo above)